Our Customers

People talk about us:

1. Anthony B.

I was looking for an authentic NYC classic slice and I stumbled on this spot. The vibe of the restaurant is nice, very accommodating and customer friendly. I ordered two slices, two canned sodas and and order of mozzarella sticks to share with my little bro, I was kinda disappointed when the total came out. And felt I was overcharged Initially. Almost 25 bucks for two slices two sodas and a few mozz sticks. I think that's a bit much. However the quality and taste of everything was top notch! But the high prices are definitely a turn off. Please consider making some combo discounts. A slice and soda shouldn't be more than $5 I know we don't live in the $1 slice world anymore but there is a beauty in the affordability and quality of authentic food. I would come here so much more often if the prices were a bit lower.

2. Mike M.

Very good pizza. Spicy margarita was on point and crispy and the stuffed mushroom pizza was tasty

3. Doug N.

Fucking amazing! I had the best gluten free pizza I have ever had here. It may well have been the best pizza I've ever had. The crust was thin, crispy and delicious. The toppings were generous and delicious. They were super friendly. The pizza was ready when they said it would. The decor really shouted pizzeria, and even at 10:30 pm on a Tuesday night the place was hopping. I cannot recommend Tony's enough. You will be so thankful you got a pizza here.

4. Michelle A.

Came All The Way from California to eat here and damn it was worth it. Best Lasagna I've had by far .. place was Clean and Staff were Super Sweet .. I'll definitely be back before I head home to Cali..

5. Greg D.

So I was on Knickerbocker Avenue this Easter Sunday 4/9/23 around 6:pm and I just wasn't feeling all that Spanish food today I was actually craving Italian and believe it or not there's an Italian cook in this kitchen !!! This is a real deal Still Italian owned & operated Pizzeria and restaurant..... I was craving penny à la vodka and the slice, which both were delicious.... My vodka sauce was perfect with a lil chunky tomato's and with a lil prosciutto chopped up nice & creamy & my pasta is cooked to perfection al dente !! They give you a lil twisted garlic bread with melted cheese in the middle which did its job helping me scoop all that yummy sauce out from my plate !!! Move over garlic knots & Italian bread & hello twisty hot garlic cheesy stick !!! Also they served me a lil Indy garden salad with Italian dressing also very good ... The slice I choose was their margarita with fresh mozzarella and basil, the crust was super thin & crispy & the sauce & fresh mozzarella was delicious !!! Sorry for no picture but the slice had no chance I was starving !!! Lol The restaurant is very clean with plenty of seating and the counter servers we're very polite & fast .. They are extremely busy over here with pizza alone for a holiday they had over 15 different kinds of fresh pies to go by the slice .... Deserts they definitely got ya covered over here; take a look, gelato, numerous cake slices, as well as whole cakes, big selection to please everyone !! Definitely coming back when in the area and definitely telling my co workers about this place ... By the way that pasta dish with the twisty bread & the side salad with a slice and a can soda $ 20 bucks well worth it !! A must try !!! Thanks, Greg D / NYCDOT EMERGENCY JOLT TASK TEAM.

6. Paula L.

Seriously awesome food. The other day we put in an order for rice balls with vodka sauce, pesto sauce, and tomato sauce on top. We got the upside down pie and the Caesar salad as an extra thing. Everything was excellent. i ordered the greek salad today for lunch. it was fantastic.

7. Alex K.

VEGAN REVIEW! Tony's is such a great spot! It's a chill and authentic pizza place that's been serving up the classics since the 70's, complete with vegan offerings. They always have a vegan cheese slice on deck, and you can add other toppings to your slice including vegan meat and a variety of veggies. If you prefer a whole pie, you can grab a vegan cheese or vegan pepperoni, as well as making your own, of course. I've gotten cheese slices and whole pepperoni pies before, and both were fantastic! Tony's also offers vegan desserts in the form of sorbet and even vegan cake slices! Aside from the fact that they have plenty of vegan options, Tony's has great service. The guys behind the counter are super friendly and funny, a true testament to this Bushwick institution. When they heard it was my birthday one night that we came in, they had everyone sing and gave me a free slice of vegan cake. It absolutely made my night and on subsequent visits the staff have been just as friendly and cool! Needless to say, Tony's is my go-to whenever I'm craving a classic New York slice or pie in Bushwick, and it should be yours, too :)

8. Sarah K.

Fabulous pizzeria all around! I went for the first time today and the person working the counter was incredibly patient as I questioned the menu. The pizza was ready in about 25 minutes, and it was DELICIOUS. Everyone loved the pizza. The ingredients were fresh and delicious. Highly recommend the egg and hash brown pizza - we put bacon on it. Helpful tip: There were 6 of us and we got 2 larges (because we eat a lot normally). It was actually wayyyy too much. We ended up with a whole large leftover. Next time we would get 2 mediums.

9. Joseph T.

I'd rate Tony's three and a half stars. We shared the three sauce slice which had a spicy red sauce (I believe arrabiata), a vodka sauce, and a pesto drizzle with some fresh mozzarella slices. Toppings were good. Dough reminded me a bit more of the dough used for sausage rolls than for pizza. Crust was pretty thick and dense. Their forte is specialty slices. Lots of varieties including but not limited to Buffalo chicken, bbq chicken, macaroni and cheese, penne, ceasar salad, taco, and many more. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating.